Search This Blog

Tuesday, January 8, 2019

Mina Hubbard: The Woman Who Charted the Last American Wilderness


By Kristy McCaffrey

Mina Benson Hubbard, A winter picnic ca. 1901
(courtesy of Betty Cawkill Ellis)
In 1903, Mina Hubbard’s husband, Leonidas, died from starvation while trying to be the first non-native to trek across the interior of Labrador, at the time one of the last unmapped areas of North America. The other members of his expedition—Dillon Wallace, a portly middle-aged lawyer, and George Elson, a half-Scot, half-Cree guide—had left him alone while going for help.

Mina was devastated. When she encouraged Wallace to pen a book to memorialize her husband, her grief soon turned to outrage. Wallace portrayed her husband as an ill-prepared amateur, and he planned to finish the unsuccessful mission. Mina decided to reclaim her husband’s honor by completing the trip herself. When the press caught wind of the competition, the idea that a woman would attempt such a thing was truly scandalous.

While her husband’s expedition had been poorly planned, Mina prepared herself by learning mapping skills, investigating supplies and equipment, and consulting with men who had already traveled into parts of Labrador. She also persuaded George Elson to accompany her, as well as hiring three additional part-native guides.

Both Mina and Wallace launched their trips in June 1905. Not only was it outrageous for a woman to lead an expedition at the turn of the 20th century, she would also spend months alone in the wilderness with four men. Mina chafed over their protectiveness and would occasionally journey on her own, worrying them to no end. “They said to me they never were on a trip before where the women didn’t do what they were told,” wrote Hubbard.

Mina Hubbard and three men around campfire, 1905.
(Coll-241, Archives & Special Collections, Memorial University, Canada)

Despite the racial and gender differences, Mina and her team became close over the next two months. They navigated raging rivers, scaled boulders, and suffered intense clouds of mosquitos and black flies. Mina surveyed the land, took latitude readings and snapped photographs, as well as naming rivers and rapids. She also made contact with the Naskapi Indians.

Wallace’s team had taken a different route and were plagued with poor navigation and disasters. They completed their trek six weeks after Mina Hubbard. The ensuing headlines made Mina famous.

In the end, however, questions remained over how a humble and farm-raised girl from Ohio could travel more than 550 miles in the rugged wilderness, and she was dogged with rumors that she had had an illicit affair with George Elson.

Several years after the journey, Mina married the scion of a coal-mining fortune and settled in an English mansion. She never undertook another expedition. She died at the age of 86 by walking in front of an oncoming train, and some speculate that it had been on purpose.

Connect with Kristy


12 comments:

  1. This is fascinating -- my mind is off on all sorts of fantastic adventures with her.

    But that last bit, caught my breath. Omgoodness.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What an amazing woman. She did everything on her own terms, including her death.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As gruesome as her ending was, you're right. She chose it.

      Delete
  3. I have great admiration for her willpower and determination, but that last line came as a real shocker. Makes me wonder what happened in her later life to cause her to possibly end her life. Perhaps a terminal illness which she couldn't face? Fascinating woman and role model.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wondered that too. Obviously, she wasn't happy. It's almost as if she found herself and her freedom, but then suppressed it again until the end of her life.

      Delete
  4. Dang! First of all, I am so impressed by how she got her skills together, made her preparations, and had the courage to carry off an expedition to recover her husband's honor.

    Of course, the press being the thrill seeking exploitive people they are even to this day, made a mockery of this courageous and intelligent woman. It seems they always attempt to destroy the character of anyone who has initiative, especially a woman.

    I thought her story would end happily, but I am so sorry to hear how it actually ended and the speculation that followed.

    What an interesting blog. Thank you, Kristy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I found her story fascinating too. To be such a brave woman and then she still had to live under the strictures of society.

      Delete
  5. She was certainly a feminist trailblazer. I, too, wonder if she had a terminal illness at the end. Wow.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, something was going on that made her want to end it. Certainly fodder for a story.

      Delete
  6. We are ever surprised by women to lived life on their own terms, yet there were more than we realize. Thank you for adding yet another forgotten trailblazer. Doris

    ReplyDelete