Search This Blog

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Questionable Place Names in Arizona by Kristy McCaffrey

By Kristy McCaffrey

Arizona has its share of place names that might make people cringe today, dating back to a colorful past and regional biases.

Throughout the state there are at least 15 geographic features whose names include "Negro." This was actually an improvement that took place in 1963 when the U.S. Geological Survey updated designations that contained a different n-word. These places include Negro Ben Peak, Negro Ben Spring and Negro Flat. But not every name is linked to racist terminology—Cerro Negro, a summit in Pima County, gets its name from the Spanish words meaning "black hill."
Negro Ben Peak
Today, the word "squaw" is considered offensive. A rather prominent site in the Phoenix area, Squaw Peak, was renamed Piestewa Peak in 2003, after the first Native American woman to die in combat in the U.S. military in Iraq. But there are still at least a dozen features in the state with the word "squaw" in the name—two Squaw Buttes, two Squaw Creeks and six other Squaw Peaks.
Piestewa Peak
The Chinaman Trail, a 2.6-mile hiking trail in the Coronado National Forest, got its name because of the Chinese laborers who constructed it around the turn of the century. There are two China Peaks in Arizona. In Cochise County, Chinese people from California financed a mine in the area; in Graham County, chinaberry trees grew in the vicinity.
China Peak
Skull Valley, near Prescott, got its name after a battle between Yavapai and Maricopa Indians. The dead were never removed. When settlers moved in, they were forced to build on land littered with the remains of human skulls.
Skull Valley
Bloody Basin, north of Phoenix, speaks to a deadly skirmish as well, but the name more likely originated when a herd of sheep crossed a bridge that gave way, sending the animals tumbling to the rocks below.
Bloody Basin
The most provocative name, however, is Helen's Dome in southeastern Arizona. Designated for a hill that lies within sight of Fort Bowie—and is shaped like a breast—it was reportedly christened after the well-endowed wife of an officer in residence at the fort. The original name was Helen's Tit, but was later softened to Helen's Dome.
Helen's Dome
While many place names have been changed, they are so numerous—with many in remote locations—that the Arizona State Board on Geographic and Historic Names considers name changes only when a petition is submitted.

Connect with Kristy
Blog ~ Pathways

Stay up-to-date on the latest news from Kristy.
Sign-up for her newsletter and be entered each month for Amazon gift cards and autographed books.




14 comments:

  1. Aren't people funny? While the names of places and landmarks can be considered offensive, they do speak to the people of past generations. A boon to historians. Having said that, wow what a plethora of fascinating names Arizona has, and what a history. Thanks for sharing, Doris

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for stopping by, Doris. What's offensive often changes over time, doesn't it? But some vulgarities stand the test of time. And, as the last one illustrates, a sense of humor is timeless.

      Delete
  2. Interesting post Kristy . Its true offence changes over time. I can't imagine what would be said if we tried to use any of these names today. It's got me wondering now, how many 'offensive' names do we have over here in UK? One town that is close to where I live, whilst not too offensive, is not somewhere I'd like to live, its called Ramsbottom! Interesting! Great post thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jill,
      LOL, I'm sure we could all find something untoward in our area if we looked!

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very interesting article, Kristy. I'm not that familiar with Arizona, so this was all news to me. It is too bad that the term "squaw" had become a derogatory word. I don't think when it was originally used by the native people that it was considered an insult. I think it is the connotation that developed when the Europeans started using that word that made it so negative. Still, it warms my heart to know that one peak was renamed to honor a Native American woman who lost her life in Iraq.

    Robyn Echols writing as Zina Abbott

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Robyn,
      It is a wonderful tribute that the peak was renamed. Thanks for stopping by!

      Delete
  5. Highly entertaining blog. You have to wonder what people were thinking when they come up with these names. My favorite is Intercourse, PA. LOL
    All the very best to you, Kristy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sarah,
      I've not heard of that town in PA. What were they thinking? I sometimes wonder if typographical errors occur. My aunt lived in Cornville, AZ for a long time, but it was supposed to be called Cohnville, but when the application for the post office was placed, the name was written illegibly. Thanks for stopping by!

      Delete
    2. Yeah, Intercourse, PA is a colorful name, that's for sure. I think the story behind the name is way back in the founding and settling days, there was a horse race course and people came from miles around to race. But still... 0_o

      Delete
  6. Kristy, what a fun post! Some of those place names are definitely not PC.

    I grew up near Succor Creek. When I looked into the history of it, it was originally named Sucker Creek because miners would plant fool's gold in it to keep the greenhorns away from their claims. But around the turn of the century, newspaper editors changed it to Succor Creek, as in giving succor to those in need, because they thought the original name was vulgur. Ahem.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't know, I don't think Sucker Creek is all that bad of a name. And it speaks to the humor of the people at the time. :-)

      Delete
  7. Here in southeastern Colorado, the high school mascot in the town of Lamar is/are the Savages with a Native American image. Needless to say, there's an on-going controversy over changing it and so far, the school/town isn't budging.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kaye,
      I'll bet there's a big uproar over that one. I can appreciate, however, that the Native Americans want it changed.

      Delete