In celebration of C. A. Asbrey's latest, In All Innocence, I thought it would be fun to have the protagonist of my novel Courting Anna interview her series heroine, Abigail. Thanks to Christine for playing along -- Abi's responses are hers.
Manuscript found in a
file of old documents pertaining to 19th century lawyer Anna
Harrison Brown, a copy of which was sent to author Cate Simon by a historian at
the University of Montana.
Abigail . . . MacKay,
is it? I’m so pleased to meet you – when
I found out you’d be passing through Chicago at the same time I was, I couldn’t
resist asking for this interview. I’m a
member of the Equity Club. We’re a
corresponding society of women lawyers throughout the United States and
territories, and if you can believe it, we have over a hundred members. Of course, we’re very interested in other
roles that women take with regard to the law, and some time ago, I had the
opportunity to meet with another female Pinkerton. She wasn’t free to speak as she was still
working for the agency. One of the first things she said to me was, “Get Abi if
you can – she has some stories she could tell . . . . “
So, my first question
is, how did you join the Pinkertons?
Thanks, Anna. I’m happy with MacKay as I’ve used numerous
names in my life. MacKay is the name I was born with, and Scottish women never
legally lose their maiden name.
It’s lovely to meet a fellow professional woman. It’s so
rare to meet one at all, let alone in a different field. I couldn’t resist
tagging this meeting onto a visit with my sister. She lives in Chicago after
her husband was hanged for murder, but that’s a whole other story. Anyway, I
digress.
We had immigrated
from Scotland, and my father started a distillery in Brooklyn. He did very well
and made a fortune, but fell prey to a protection racket. Being very stubborn,
and obstinately fearless, he refused to pay up. Allan Pinkerton had been a
friend of my father’s back in Scotland. They were both chartists, and came into
contact professionally as my father made whisky, and Allan Pinkerton made
barrels. It was logical that my family would turn to him for help, and even
more logical that Allan Pinkerton would have a vested interest in finding the
killer of an old friend.
I fell into the Pinkertons almost by accident. I had no idea
women did this kind of work. Prior to that, I was living a happy domestic life
with my lawyer husband, and expecting a child. I thought my life was mapped out
for me.
I was very close to
my father, and shared his love of science and books. I was devastated when he
was killed, especially as the murder came just a few months after I lost my
husband to peritonitis. I actually found the body, and the stress caused me to
lose the baby boy I was carrying. I developed a deep melancholia, and found
myself unable to eat or get out of bed. After a few weeks I found myself
obsessing over the murder, and on getting justice for my father. Poking around
and asking questions gave me something to get up for, and before I knew it I
was pushing myself deep into the investigation and trampling all over the
carefully-laid work the Pinkertons were already doing. Allan Pinkerton was simultaneously annoyed
and impressed by how far I got, but said I was easier to control if he actually
employed me. We did solve the murder, and as I’d lost the people I cared for
most in the world, I thought I might as well help others get the same justice.
I had dreamed of having a family and a home, but those things had gone. Being a
Pinkerton Detective gave my life some meaning.
What a fascinating story; and I’m so very
sorry. I was lucky enough to practice
law with my father for a number of years before we lost him. So you came to the Pinkertons through
tragedy, but from what my informant tells me, you flourished there. What did you enjoy – or value? – most about
the job?
Helping people. Especially people who don’t have a voice;
the poor, the women, the children, the immigrants, and all those who lack the
ability to fight back. That’s a quality I get from my father. Being a chartist
he believed strongly that ordinary people should have a voice. Allan Pinkerton
shared that belief, and employed black men and women as agents, as well as
white women like me. I like to think I made a difference, and put away some
truly evil people.
That’s
marvelous. We’ve – that is, my father
and I, and now my partner, Jonathan Cranbrook, and I, have reached out to
people who need our help, too – in particular a number of the natives whose
lands are nearby – the Blackfeet and the Crow nation. And recently we learned how difficult it was
for a woman, a close friend of ours with every reason on her side, to obtain a
divorce. What was your greatest
challenge?
The answer to that will always be the personal challenges;
when people close to me are hurt or killed. Those impact on me very deeply, and
I have a tendency to be almost paralyzed by grief before it galvanizes me into
action. I think too deeply about things,
and hold my feelings inside rather than always express them. That’s not always a good thing, as they can
turn bad and poison the soul. My husband has taught me to flush them out. On the other hand, such tragedies have given
me a special insight into the pain and suffering of victims, so I try to turn
that into a positive force for good.
I think all of my most challenging cases involved children.
They are especially vulnerable to exploitation.
Oh goodness, yes. It can be heartbreaking. I’ve taken in several orphan girls over the
years, and it’s overwhelming to think how many more there are out there with no
one to help them.
You must have
encountered some interesting opponents during your time at the agency. Who
would you say was your greatest adversary?
If you mean greatest, as in best, that would definitely be
my husband. We were on different sides of the law when we met. I was even sent
to bring him in, but he most definitely wasn’t what I expected. Most criminals
are stupid, so when they talk about a clever criminal it’s all relative, and
most are still pretty dumb. Nat was different. He had a brilliant, quicksilver
mind. He is mostly self-taught, and like most autodidacts, he has an expansive
and eclectic set of skills. We share a love of science and an interest in new
technologies, so really enjoy attending exhibitions and fairs to see them
demonstrated.
I expected to meet a cunning, ruthless, and selfish outlaw.
The man I met was charming, funny, humane, and damaged. Circumstances robbed
him of his childhood, and he was raised by an uncle only a little older than he
was. Jake found them a room at a brothel and did odd jobs around the place to
allow Nat to attend school. As you can imagine, under those poor influences, they
quickly drifted into a life of crime. Unfortunately, they were very good at it,
and petty crime turned into grand larceny. We both fought our attraction for a
long time as it could destroy both our lives.
Eventually though, the inevitable happened. Both Nat, and
his uncle Jake, decided to go straight. I’m happy to say they turned into
honest and productive members of society.
I think you know full
well I didn’t mean best, but most challenging – however, it sounds like the
answer would be the same in either case – and quite a story it is! I met my own husband through the bars of a
sheriff’s lockup when I was called in to defend him, so I’m hardly one to judge,
in any case. But presumably you had some
interesting coworkers, as well. Who
would you say was your staunchest ally?
Apart from Nat and Jake, that would be a lady called Dr.
Davida Cadwalader – Vida for short. She worked for the Pinkerton Detective
agency during the war as an agent and was arrested for spying. She escaped. but
continued working for the agency. The war gave her an opportunity to move from
nursing to studying medicine, and she became a doctor. From there she travelled
to Zurich to study under Wilhelm Wundt, and became what most people call an
alienist, but she sometimes calls herself a psychologist.
She not only trained me when I joined the agency, but helped
me work through my deep melancholia at losing my baby. We soon became fast
friends, even though she’s much older than me. She’s very brave and loyal, and
an adherent of rational dress, she often wears a man’s frock coat and top hat.
Vida doesn’t care a jot what people think of her. She’s the person I turn to
for unqualified support, as my family can never know I was a Pinkerton
Detective. They think I work as a governess, just to keep myself busy, and they
really wouldn’t understand the dangers and pressures I’ve faced. My life was a
secret even to my family.
Vida and Nat clashed when they first met, but they soon came
to understand one another.
I’ve had an
opportunity to look over some of your case files, and I’m fascinated by your
knowledge of forensics – not something I’ve had much of a chance to study. Can
you tell me a little bit about your background in the science of solving
crimes?
I was always interested in science, and my father encouraged
me. I very much doubt he ever thought I’d use it professionally, but he did
encourage me to get an education. He thought I might be able to help my
children with their own studies. He supported women being educated as it meant
that their families were more likely to prosper. He came from a poor background
and knew the value of education.
The agency was very keen to use the scientific methods being
used to solve crimes in Europe. The works of people like James Marsh, Alexander
Lacassagne, Hans Gross, Joseph Bell, Edmund Locard, Henry Goddard, Alphonse
Bertillon, and William Herschel all inspired Allan Pinkerton to use the most
modern methods in solving crime. He also saw the benefits of keeping files on
criminals and criminal intelligence, and I have found these records invaluable
in solving crime. It’s how I found out my sister’s husband’s previous wives all
died in suspicious circumstances. It helped save her life.
There are tests we can conduct ourselves after training, and
people like Vida and Doctor MacIvor are employed to help the detectives with
more complex scientific matters. I have to say I enjoy that side of things and
try to keep up to date with all the advances.
I carried a basic kit of chemicals, and a microscope, for
work in the field. I enjoyed the challenge of analyzing clues to find the
culprit. I actually miss it sometimes.
I know a bit about
William Herschel, anyway. I understand
his sister Caroline was quite an astronomer, herself. Of course, she didn’t have the same
opportunities that he did. Which brings
me to my next question: one of the
biggest objections to women in both of our professions is that we belong in the
home, being protected by our menfolk from the cruel and dangerous world. In a case that my legal sisters will remember
well and unhappily, Bradwell v. Illinois, Justice Bradley, of the U.S. Supreme
Court, went so far as to say it was the law of the Creator. What do you make of that?
Ha! I’ve seen too many women who needed to be protected from
the menfolk to fall for that. Women are at the forefront of tragedy and cruelty
all the time. We care for the sick, wash the dead and prepare them for burial.
We give birth, wipe bottoms of the young as well as the extremely old, and
routinely make a very little go a long way. We carry the emotional burden for
the whole family, and face violence in the home which we are expected to either
tolerate, or cover up. That attitude isn’t protecting people; it’s making them
less prepared to face reality, and keeping people from reaching their full
potential. Strength isn’t a male or female quality. It’s a human one. Sometimes
even the strongest can be weak, and it’s good for a strong man to have someone
to fall back on. That person is often a wife, mother, sister, daughter, or
aunt. Many women don’t want to do the work either of us have done, and that’s
just fine. Many men don’t either. However, if we’re both capable and keen I can
see no reason why we shouldn’t – and that goes for men too. One of the reasons
many of us came to the USA is that the social strictures of the old world
stopped clever men from a lower class from moving up in the world. I look
forward to a day when people of both genders are limited only by their
abilities. I wonder if that will ever happen.
Speaking of matters
domestic – I’m told you’re quite a cook.
That’s a talent I envy and do not share; fortunately for my nearest and
dearest we’ve never been in a situation where anyone’s had to survive on my
cooking for any period of time. Tell me
about your favorite thing to cook – although my readers and I are lady lawyers,
we are still ladies, after all.
Oh, yes. I love to cook. I find it very relaxing, and do my
best thinking when doing mundane things like peeling and chopping. Some people
think it’s odd that women could want both a career and a family, but I don’t
find it odd in the least. I want to explore everything nature gave me.
While a number of our
members are single ladies, others of us are married – and I firmly believe that
every woman should make the choice that’s right for her. It’s simply that we should have choices, the
same as men do. But back to food!
There’s a Scottish desert called Cranochan which my family
love. It’s usually made with honey, toasted oats and whisky. I hate whisky,
despite my family making their fortune in it, so I’ve made my own version,
which I call Twisted Cranochan. It couldn’t be simpler. Raspberries and the
orange liqueur go beautifully together.
Twisted Cranochan
For the shortbread
1 cup butter
1 cup sugar
3 cups flour
Preparation
Thoroughly cream sugar and butter until it . Add 2 1/2 cups
of the flour and mix thoroughly. Turn out onto a surface floured with remaining
1/2 cup of flour. Knead dough until it cracks on the surface. If it doesn’t
come together add a little buttermilk to help it blend.
Roll out 1/4-inch thick and cut out with cutters. Prick with
a fork tines in lines and place on gray paper or on greased and floured baking
sheets. Bake in a hot oven for about 45 to 55 minutes or until lightly browned.
For the cranochan
At least 2 1/2 cups of heavy cream
1 pound of fresh raspberries (out of season you can use
canned)
Around 7 tablespoons of triple sec or Grand Marnier
Crumbled shortbread to taste
Preparation
Whip the cream and place some of the raspberries in the
bottom of a dish. Liberally sprinkle with the alcohol to taste. Top with
crumbled shortbread. Add a layer of whipped cream. Repeat these steps until the
dish is full. Individual tall glasses can be used if preferred.
That sounds
delightful!
You mentioned that
your husband was once your adversary; I told you in response that mine was once
a client. Jeremiah had a past – there was
a pretty big reward out on him when we first crossed paths, and until the statute of limitations ran out on some of the things he'd done, he was always looking over his shoulder. But he’d changed his ways before we ever met,
and I knew how hard he was striving to lead an honest life. Anyway, as a defense attorney I always look
for the good in my clients, and it wasn’t hard to find, in his case. But a Pinkerton and her quarry – that is
quite a romantic story, I’m certain. Do
you mind telling me a little more, off the record?
Nat was special. He had something unique which shone through
the rough patina. I’ve spoken to enough criminals to know that nobody is all
good, or all bad. We all have a darker side, and many criminals also have a
softer side. What was refreshing about Nat was that he was honest about being dishonest.
He didn’t deliver a sob story, even though he actually had one. He didn’t
justify his crimes, even though I found out much later that he hit out at the organizations
which orphaned him, and which tried to sell him and his uncle as cheap labor as
children. He never robbed ordinary people, and had a code of morality regarding
violence. I’m not defending him. Nobody excoriated his terrible choices more
than me, but there was a genuine humanity and decency at his core. I pushed him
to make a choice between honesty and dishonesty, and even though he couldn’t
change his past, he could change his future.
I know lots of women think they can change a man. I’m
cynical enough and experienced enough to know that you can’t. I didn’t change
Nat - he’s still the same old rogue. He’s still a mixture of good and bad, but
we all are. Just like everyone else he makes choices which enhance his life. It
used to be easy money, poker, and a wild life. The difference is that now is
his home, career, and family enhances his life.
But hey, on top of all that we all like to flirt with danger
sometimes. I know I did. We just don’t expect it to get serious.
Indeed. I was engaged when I was young, and after my
fiance died, I’d decided that no other man would ever understand me the way
that he had. And so I was determined to
stay single. In a strange way, danger
was my safe choice, since Jeremiah wasn't in a position to settle down, not when we first met. But life has a way
of surprising us, doesn’t it?
It’s been delightful
to meet you and hear your story, and I’m sure our members will be fascinated by
your career – and by that wondrous-sounding dessert! All the best for whatever’s next for you and
yours, and I hope our paths cross again.
Further research found
that the answers to all but the last of these questions were published in the
Equity Club’s Annual for 18--.
Read
more about Abi in the Innocents Series:
C.A's Social
Media:
Read more about Anna in Courting Anna:
US: amzn.to/2Zn7Iyo
Cate's Social Media:
Newsletter:
Coming Soon
Twitter: @CateSimon3